The Discovery
Signals From Another World
Keith Hearne, April 12, 1975, University of Hull, England. Lucid dreamer Alan Worsley performed pre-arranged left-right eye movements during REM sleep, recorded on an electrooculogram. Hearne described it as receiving signals from another world. Published in his dissertation (1978), but largely ignored by mainstream science.
Stephen LaBerge, January 13, 1978, Stanford University. LaBerge himself as subject successfully signaled from a lucid dream using eye movements, confirmed by the combination of EEG (brain waves), EOG (eye movements), and EMG (muscle activity). For the first time in history: dreams reported in real time.
The journal Science rejected the paper, the reviewer refused to believe it was possible. Nature called the topic "insufficiently interesting." Finally published in Perceptual and Motor Skills (1980).
Forty years on the signal became a conversation. In 2021 four laboratories, in Evanston, Paris, Osnabrück and Nijmegen, asked questions of people who were lucid inside REM sleep, with spoken words, tones, lights and touch, and received answers by eye movements or facial muscles: yes or no, and the result of a small subtraction. Of 36 participants, six answered correctly 29 times. Delphine Oudiette and Isabelle Arnulf led the Paris arm. Most attempts got no answer at all, which the authors say plainly, and that is the honest size of the opening.
The traffic can run the other way too. In 2014 Ursula Voss and colleagues in Frankfurt applied weak alternating current to the scalps of sleepers in REM and found that 25 and 40 hertz, and no other frequency, raised the sleepers' own ratings of knowing they were dreaming, in people who had never had a lucid dream. The effect was modest and the press overstated it, which the later commentary corrected. Two decades before any of this, Mary Arnold-Forster had taught herself the same awareness without a laboratory, and her 1921 book is on the women and dreams timeline.
The same eye signals made it possible to time a dream from inside. Counting to ten in a lucid dream takes about as long as counting awake, while movements take longer, squats roughly 40 percent longer in one study. Erlacher and colleagues found the same pattern with walking and a gymnastics routine in 2014, and the page on clocks, time and reading in dreams follows the question further.