A woman in a black dress floating on her back above a lawn, trees in blossom behind her
◎☽✦◈◇⊕
1867 to 1968 · Paris, Bussum, Wiltshire, Oxford

Lucid Dreaming Before the Laboratory: The People Who Taught Themselves

Lucid dreaming was proved in a sleep laboratory in 1975. It was practised, written about and taught for more than a century before that, by a French marquis who published anonymously, a Dutch psychiatrist who gave the state its name, and an Englishwoman who flew in a dress of straight folds. This is their story, told from their own books.

In essence

Lucid dreaming, knowing that you are dreaming while the dream goes on, was described by Aristotle, recorded by Augustine in 415 CE, practised in Tibet for a thousand years, and studied in the first person by the Marquis d'Hervey de Saint-Denys, who published his method anonymously in Paris in 1867. Frederik van Eeden gave it the name lucid dream in 1913, meaning insight rather than brightness, and Mary Arnold-Forster taught herself to end nightmares and to fly in dreams and wrote it up in 1921. The laboratory proof of 1975 confirmed what these people had been saying for a century.

At a glance

  • Hervey de Saint-Denys kept a dream diary from his teens and experimented inside his dreams for decades; his 1867 book, nearly five hundred pages, was known to Freud, who never found a copy, and to the Surrealists, who did.
  • Van Eeden recorded 352 lucid dreams between 1898 and 1912 and read his paper to the Society for Psychical Research in 1913; Arnold-Forster's Studies in Dreams of 1921 describes learning the state in childhood and teaching it to others.
  • Oliver Fox called it the dream of knowledge in 1939, Celia Green brought the term back in Lucid Dreams in 1968, and seven years later Keith Hearne recorded the first signal from inside a dream. The science page continues from there.

Where the science stands

What is established: that lucid dreaming is a real state of REM sleep, proved by agreed eye signals in 1975 and replicated many times since, and that it can be learned, which the laboratory has also shown. Everything on this page comes from before that proof, and it is history, not evidence. Each of these writers reported their own dreams, from memory, on waking, with no witness and every reason to find what they were looking for. That they described the same state independently, in three languages, is what makes the history worth telling, and it is still not data.

Two things stay open. Who came first is argued: Hervey de Saint-Denys wrote about the state in 1867, van Eeden named it in 1913, and whether the French book already used the phrase is disputed. And the claim that Arnold-Forster found lucid dreaming on her own and devised the first ways to induce it comes from a single historical article of 2026, carefully argued and new, which is how this page cites it.

The books themselves

If you want the originals rather than a summary, these are free to read:

The books this page draws on are listed in Sources and References.

Before the books

Aristotle, Augustine and the monks of Tibet

The oldest notice of the state is a sentence. In On Dreams, one of the short treatises on sleep that follow his work on the soul, Aristotle observes that when a sleeper sees something in a dream, something within can often tell them that what appears is only a dream. He does not build on it. It sits in an argument about how dreams are made from the leftover movements of the senses, and for two thousand years nobody built on it either.

Augustine gives the first story. In a letter of 415 CE to his friend Evodius he tells of Gennadius, a physician in Carthage who doubted there was any life after death. Gennadius dreamed of a young man who led him to a city full of singing, and the next night the same young man returned and asked whether he remembered where they had met. Gennadius described the earlier dream, and the young man asked whether he had seen it asleep or awake. Asleep, said Gennadius. Then you are asleep now, said the figure, and seeing this in sleep, and the dream went on with the dreamer knowing what it was. Augustine tells it as an argument about the soul. Read today it is a lucid dream, recorded by a bishop, sixteen centuries before the word.

The one culture that made a discipline of the state did so for the same reason Augustine told his story. In the Tibetan practice of dream yoga, which this site describes on its own page, recognising the dream as a dream is a step towards recognising waking life as no more solid, and the teachings on it go back roughly a thousand years. Europe had no equivalent, which is why the people on the rest of this page each had to start from nothing.

1867

Hervey de Saint-Denys and the means of directing dreams

In 1867 a book of nearly five hundred pages appeared in Paris from the publisher Amyot, with a colour frontispiece of dream images and no author's name. Les rêves et les moyens de les diriger, Dreams and the Means of Directing Them, was the work of Marie-Jean-Léon Lecoq, Marquis d'Hervey de Saint-Denys, a scholar of Chinese who held a chair at the Collège de France and had been writing down his dreams since he was a boy. The book is built on that diary. He describes how he learned, over years, to notice the dream while it ran, and then what he did with the noticing: calling up places he wanted to see, testing whether a dream figure would answer a question, watching what changed when he changed it.

His method was plain. Write every dream down on waking, so that the habit of attending to dreams carries into sleep. Learn to recognise the signs that one is dreaming. Then act. He was a careful observer as well as an enthusiast, and the book reports what would not obey him alongside what would. Freud read about it and wrote in The Interpretation of Dreams that he had been unable to obtain a copy. André Breton found one and discussed it in The Communicating Vessels, which is how the Surrealists came to the idea that a dream could be worked in.

The book stayed in French for over a century. An abridged English translation by Nicholas Fry, edited by the psychiatrist Morton Schatzman, appeared from Duckworth in 1982, and a full translation edited by Phil Baker has appeared only recently. The original is free to read, scanned, on the Internet Archive.

1913

Frederik van Eeden gives the state a name

Frederik van Eeden was a Dutch psychiatrist, novelist and reformer, a founder of a utopian colony and a translator of Tagore, and from 1896 he kept a diary of his own dreams. From 1898 he kept a separate record of one kind, and by December 1912 he had 352 of them. In 1913 he read a paper on them to the Society for Psychical Research in London, and it was printed in the Society's Proceedings, volume 26, under the title A Study of Dreams.

It is there that the term lucid dream is first fixed in print. Van Eeden chose the word in the sense of a lucid interval, the clear stretch in an illness of the mind, so that lucid meant having insight, not vivid. He sorted his dreams into kinds, called this kind the most interesting and the most worth careful study, and described testing the dream from inside, trying to break a glass, trying to shout, noting what resisted. He also described dreams he called demoniacal, in which figures mocked him after a lucid dream had ended, and he wrote about them with the same care, which is more than most of his successors managed.

Whether Hervey de Saint-Denys had used the French phrase rêve lucide first is argued, mostly by people who would like him to have. It does not matter much. Van Eeden is the one who gave the word its meaning and put it in a scientific proceedings, and it is his meaning the laboratory kept.

1921

Mary Arnold-Forster learns to fly

Mary Arnold-Forster was an English writer and gardener, the widow of a Liberal politician, living in Wiltshire, and in 1921 George Allen and Unwin published her Studies in Dreams, with a foreword by Morton Prince, the Boston psychologist who had founded the Journal of Abnormal Psychology. It is a book for general readers, in plain English, and it describes a method she had found as a child. Her nightmares ended, she says, when she taught herself to say, inside the dream, that it was only a dream, and that she could wake if she chose. The nightmare stopped having power once it was named.

As an adult she went further. She taught herself to fly in dreams, and describes the little push off the ground that started a flight and the dress she wore for it, a flying dress of straight close folds that fell three or four inches below her feet, so that she need not worry about her skirts. The First World War had filled her nights with the dead, and part of the book is about turning that too. She argues that the knowledge of dreaming while dreaming can be learned, that it can be passed on to children, and that a dream once recognised can be changed from inside.

For a century her book was read as a curiosity. In 2026 the historians Paloma Burek and Renaud Evrard published an article in the French journal L'Évolution psychiatrique arguing that she arrived at lucid dreaming independently of Hervey de Saint-Denys and devised the first methods for inducing it, and that her part was afterwards minimised, a pattern the historian Margaret Rossiter named the Matilda effect. This page cites that article as what it is, a careful recent argument, and puts her where she belongs in the sequence. She is also on the Women and Dreams timeline.

1939 to 1968

The dream of knowledge, and the word comes back

Between the wars the state was kept alive at the edges of respectable study. Oliver Fox, an English writer on what he called astral projection, published a book under that title in 1939, gathered from articles he had written in the 1920s, and in it he named the dream of knowledge, his term for the dream in which one knows one is dreaming, and described the trouble of being unable to wake from it. His framing was occult and his observations were often exact, which is a combination the history of this subject keeps producing.

The word van Eeden had chosen came back in 1968. Celia Green, who had founded the Institute of Psychophysical Research in Oxford in 1961, published Lucid Dreams with Hamish Hamilton, a short study built on accounts she had collected, in which she argued that lucid dreams were a distinct kind of experience and not simply vivid ordinary dreams. She also predicted that they would turn out to belong to REM sleep. Seven years later, on 12 April 1975, Keith Hearne at the University of Hull recorded the volunteer Alan Worsley making agreed left-right eye movements from inside a dream, and the subject left the hands of diarists for good. What happened next, Hearne, LaBerge, Tholey and the laboratories of 2021, is on the science of lucid dreaming page.

Our lens

What the diarists still have to teach

Every person on this page learned the state the same way, by writing dreams down on waking until attention to dreams carried over into sleep, and by learning the signs that mark a dream as a dream. The laboratory has since confirmed that these are the methods that work, under names like reality testing and dream journaling, and it has added nothing that Hervey de Saint-Denys did not already do in the 1850s. The practical guide on this site sets them out.

Worth keeping from Arnold-Forster above all is the first use she found for it, which was not flying. It was ending a nightmare by naming it. The reader on this site does something adjacent by daylight, asking what a dream was made of and what the day around it was, and the two are not rivals. A dream understood in the morning and a dream recognised in the night are both ways of not being pushed around by one.

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Who first described lucid dreaming?

Nobody first. Aristotle, in his short treatise On Dreams, notes that something in the sleeper can tell them that what they see is only a dream. Augustine, in a letter of 415 CE, records a dream in which a physician named Gennadius is told by a figure in the dream that he is asleep and seeing it in sleep. Tibetan Buddhists built a practice around the state about a thousand years ago. The first person to study it in himself over years and publish the method was the Marquis d'Hervey de Saint-Denys, anonymously, in Paris in 1867.

Who coined the term lucid dream?

The Dutch psychiatrist and writer Frederik van Eeden, in A Study of Dreams, read to the Society for Psychical Research and printed in its Proceedings in 1913. He had kept a diary of his own dreams from 1896 and a separate record of this kind from 1898, 352 of them by 1912, and he chose lucid in the sense of a lucid interval, meaning insight, not brightness. Hervey de Saint-Denys had written about the same state in French forty-six years earlier, and some argue he used the phrase first, which is still disputed.

What did Hervey de Saint-Denys actually do?

He kept a diary of his dreams from his teens, trained himself to notice when he was dreaming, and then tried experiments inside the dream, steering it, testing what he could change and what changed on its own. He published the results in 1867 as Les rêves et les moyens de les diriger, Dreams and the Means of Directing Them, without his name on it, nearly five hundred pages with a colour frontispiece. Freud knew of the book and could not find a copy. It was translated into English, abridged, in 1982, and in full only recently.

Who was Mary Arnold-Forster?

An English writer and gardener who published Studies in Dreams in 1921, with a foreword by the Boston psychologist Morton Prince. As a child she had ended her nightmares by telling herself inside the dream that it was only a dream, and as an adult she taught herself to fly in dreams, wearing what she called a flying dress of straight close folds. A 2026 historical article argues she arrived at lucid dreaming independently and devised the first methods for bringing it on, and that her part in the story was afterwards left out. She is on this site's Women and Dreams timeline.

Did people control their dreams before science proved lucid dreaming existed?

Yes, and they said so in print, which is the point of this page. Hervey de Saint-Denys in 1867, van Eeden in 1913, Arnold-Forster in 1921, Oliver Fox in 1939 and Celia Green in 1968 all described knowing they were dreaming, and several described changing the dream from inside. What none of them could do was prove it to anyone else, because a dream report is a memory told on waking. That proof came in April 1975, when Keith Hearne recorded a sleeper's agreed eye signals from inside REM sleep, and the science of lucid dreaming page takes the story from there.

Where can I read these early books?

Hervey de Saint-Denys's 1867 book is scanned in full on the Internet Archive, in French, and there is now an unabridged English translation edited by Phil Baker. Van Eeden's 1913 paper is short and widely reprinted online. Arnold-Forster's Studies in Dreams is out of copyright and scanned in several digital libraries. Celia Green's Lucid Dreams of 1968 is out of print but held by most university libraries. The Sources page lists them all with the editions this page used.

Recommended reading

Go Deeper

Les rêves et les moyens de les dirigerHervey de Saint-Denys (1867)

Amyot, Paris, published anonymously. The first book-length first-person study of directing dreams, built on decades of a dream diary. Abridged in English in 1982, complete only recently.

View in Sources ↗
A Study of DreamsFrederik van Eeden (1913)

Proceedings of the Society for Psychical Research, volume 26. The paper that fixed the term lucid dream, in the sense of insight, on 352 dreams of his own.

View in Sources ↗
Studies in DreamsMary Arnold-Forster (1921)

George Allen and Unwin. Ending nightmares by naming them and learning to fly, written for ordinary readers forty years before any laboratory took the subject up.

View in Sources ↗
Lucid DreamsCelia Green (1968)

Hamish Hamilton. The book that brought van Eeden's word back and argued, seven years before the proof, that lucid dreams were a distinct kind of experience belonging to REM sleep.

View in Sources ↗
Mary Arnold-Forster and the Other Pioneers of Lucid Dreaming in Europe, 1867 to 1921Paloma Burek and Renaud Evrard (2026)

L'Évolution psychiatrique, in press. The historical case that Arnold-Forster discovered lucid dreaming independently and devised the first induction methods, and that her contribution was afterwards minimised.

View in Sources ↗

One dream is a night.

Kept together, they begin to show a thread. The Dream Journal letter arrives on the 1st and the 15th: one symbol read closely, one honest idea from the science of sleep.

Free · Twice a month max · One-click unsubscribe

And if you want to keep the dreams themselves: the Companion plan keeps what you cannot see alone.