Star trails turning in a spiral over sea stacks at night, a long exposure of passing time
◐☽✦◈◎◇

Clocks, Time and Reading in Dreams

You look at a clock in a dream and the hands will not settle. You read a sign, glance away, and the words are different when you look back. Sleep researchers have studied both, and what they found says something about how a dreaming mind keeps time.

In essence

Yes, many people see clocks, watches and phone screens in dreams, but the time they show rarely holds still. Look away and look back, and the numbers have often changed or stopped making sense.

At a glance

  • Reading, writing and arithmetic are rare in dreams, and text that does appear tends to change on a second look.
  • In the laboratory, dream time runs roughly in step with clock time. Counting in a lucid dream takes about as long as counting awake, but dream movements take longer.
  • Lucid dreamers read a line or a clock twice as a reality check, though no induction method has yet been shown to work reliably.

Where the science stands

What is measured here is small. The timing studies rest on a handful of trained lucid dreamers signalling with their eyes, and the rarity of reading comes from people rating their own dreams. Nobody has shown why dream clocks and dream text will not hold still, and the explanations below are proposals. A clock in your own dream predicts nothing about time running out in your life. What it means to you is a question your own associations answer first, and any reading of it is a lens, never a verdict.

What dreamers report

The Clock That Will Not Say the Same Thing Twice

Clocks turn up in dreams often enough that people search for them by name, and the reports have a shape. The first glance usually looks normal. The trouble starts when the dreamer looks again. The hands have moved too far, a digital display reads 4:73, or the face has lost its numbers altogether.

Lucid dreamers noticed this early and turned it into a tool. Stephen LaBerge and Howard Rheingold describe the check in Exploring the World of Lucid Dreaming (1990): read the time or a line of text, look away, and read it again. If it has changed, you are probably dreaming. They also note that a digital display tends to give itself away faster than an analogue face, which a dreaming mind can fake more convincingly.

If you are wondering what a clock in your dream might mean to you, rather than why it behaves this way, that question belongs to the clock and time symbol.

Reading, writing, numbers

Why Text Is Rare in Dreams

Ernest Hartmann, the first editor of the journal Dreaming, asked a simple question in a paper published there in 2000. How often do people dream of the three R's, reading, writing and arithmetic? In his studies people rated reading, writing and typing as far more frequent in their waking days than in their dreams. For many of them these activities fill hours of every day, and they barely reach the night at all.

That matters for the continuity hypothesis, which holds that dreams carry over what fills our waking lives. Most of waking life does carry over, but reading and calculating mostly do not. Hartmann's own explanation was that dreaming sits at one end of a range of thinking. Focused, step-by-step work lies at the other end, and dreaming is looser and more picture-led, making connections by feeling. Reading a sentence and adding up a bill are exactly the focused kind of task. His explanation is a proposal and has not been tested as such.

Dream time and clock time

How Long Does a Dream Last?

An old belief holds that a long dream can unfold in a single second. Its most famous example comes from the French scholar Alfred Maury, who described a dream of the Revolution that ended with his own execution. He woke as part of the bed fell against his neck. Freud retells the story in The Interpretation of Dreams, and for a century it stood as proof that dreams happen in a flash, built backwards from whatever wakes us.

The laboratory gave a different answer. In 1957 William Dement and Nathaniel Kleitman woke sleepers after either 5 or 15 minutes of REM sleep and asked which it had been. Most chose correctly, and the longer the REM period, the longer the dream they told.

Lucid dreamers made a sharper test possible, because they can signal from inside a dream with agreed eye movements that show up on the recording. LaBerge found in the 1980s that counting to ten in a lucid dream took about as long as counting awake. Daniel Erlacher and Michael Schredl repeated the counting in 2004 and added ten squats. The counting matched again, but the squats took roughly 40 percent longer in the dream. A follow-up study with Melanie Schädlich and Tadas Stumbrys, published in 2014, found the same pattern with walking and a gymnastics routine. The authors suggest the missing feedback from muscles, or slower processing in REM sleep, as possible reasons.

Counting

About the same length as counting awake, in every study so far.

Moving

Longer in the dream. Squats took roughly 40 percent more time.

The reality check

Reading Twice to Know You Are Dreaming

Because text and clocks are so unstable in dreams, checking them became one of the standard lucid dreaming habits. The idea is to check often enough while awake that the habit carries into a dream. There, a second look at a clock or a sentence that has changed can tell you that you are dreaming. The German researcher Paul Tholey built a similar habit around a plain question asked several times a day, "Am I dreaming?" It also catches false awakenings, the dreams in which you seem to wake up in your own bed.

The evidence for these habits is thinner than their popularity. Tadas Stumbrys and colleagues reviewed 35 studies of lucid dream induction in 2012. They judged the methods of most of them weak and found that no technique had been shown to induce lucid dreams reliably. Reading twice is a good test once you are already wondering. As a way of getting there, it remains unproven.

Did you know…

Facts That Will Surprise You

☽

Did you know a dream about a guillotine shaped a century of thinking about dream time? Alfred Maury's dream of his own execution, ended by part of his bed falling on his neck, was retold by Freud and long taken as proof that dreams happen in an instant.

☽

Did you know squats take longer in a lucid dream than awake? In Erlacher and Schredl's 2004 study, ten squats took roughly 40 percent longer in the dream, while counting took about the same time.

☽

Did you know reading barely appears in dreams? Ernest Hartmann found that people rated reading, writing and typing as far more common in waking life than in their dreams, though many spend hours on them every day.

◐

Did a clock or a page refuse to hold still last night?

Write down what it showed, if you remember, and how it felt to look at it. If you want to look at the dream as a whole, you can bring it here.

Read Your Dream

Free · No account needed · Your dream is not stored

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you see time in dreams?

Yes, many people see clocks, watches and phone screens in dreams, but the time they show rarely holds still. Look away and look back, and the numbers have often changed or stopped making sense. Lucid dreamers use exactly this as a test: a clock that will not say the same thing twice is a sign that you are dreaming.

Do clocks work in dreams?

A dream clock can look ordinary at first glance, and analogue faces in particular can seem believable. What tends to fail is a second reading. The hands jump, a digital display shows an impossible time, or the digits blur. Sleep researchers have no settled explanation for this, and the evidence comes mostly from dreamers' own reports.

Can you read in dreams?

Reading, writing and arithmetic are rare in dreams. In Ernest Hartmann's studies, published in Dreaming in 2000, people rated these activities as far more common in their waking days than in their dreams. When text does appear, it often changes on a second look, which is why lucid dreamers read a line, look away and read it again.

How long do dreams last in real time?

Laboratory work suggests dream time runs roughly in step with clock time, not in a flash. In 1957 Dement and Kleitman woke sleepers after 5 or 15 minutes of REM sleep, and most chose the right length, with longer reports after longer REM. Counting in a lucid dream takes about as long as counting awake, while dream movements take longer.

Recommended reading

Go Deeper

We Do Not Dream of the 3 R'sErnest Hartmann (2000)

Two studies on how rarely reading, writing and arithmetic reach dreams, and what that says about dreaming as a kind of thinking.

View in Sources ↗
Time for Actions in Lucid DreamsErlacher, Schädlich, Stumbrys and Schredl (2014)

Counting, walking and a gymnastics routine timed inside lucid dreams with eye signals. Counting matched waking time, movement did not.

View in Sources ↗
The Relation of Eye Movements During Sleep to Dream ActivityDement and Kleitman (1957)

Sleepers woken after 5 or 15 minutes of REM sleep mostly judged the length correctly, the first measure of dream time against clock time.

View in Sources ↗
Induction of Lucid Dreams: A Systematic Review of EvidenceStumbrys, Erlacher, Schädlich and Schredl (2012)

Thirty-five studies of lucid dream induction, reality testing among them, and the finding that none of the techniques had yet been shown to work reliably.

View in Sources ↗

One dream is a night.

Kept together, they begin to show a thread. The Dream Journal letter arrives on the 1st and the 15th: one symbol read closely, one honest idea from the science of sleep.

Free · Twice a month max · One-click unsubscribe

And if you want to keep the dreams themselves: the Companion plan keeps what you cannot see alone.