Macrobius writes the five kinds
A grammarian's commentary on Cicero fixes the classification of dreams that medieval Europe will use for a thousand years.
Commentary → Five kinds → Chaucer
Between the fall of Rome and the Renaissance, Europe did not stop thinking about dreams. It sorted them. Macrobius gave the Middle Ages five kinds, Augustine three ways of seeing, Gregory the Great six origins, and the theologians a rule for which dreams a Christian might read. Beside the theory ran a popular dream book copied for six centuries. Here is the whole system, from the texts.
Medieval Europe inherited Macrobius's five kinds of dream, written around 400 CE, and used them for a thousand years: the enigmatic somnium, the prophetic visio, the oracular oraculum, and two kinds not worth interpreting, the insomnium born of the day and the body and the visum at the edge of sleep. Augustine added three kinds of vision, Gregory the Great six origins of dreams, and Thomas Aquinas a rule for which dreams a Christian might read. Beside the theory ran the Somniale Danielis, an alphabetical dream book copied from the ninth century to the fifteenth, and in Byzantium the Oneirocriticon of Achmet, a Greek manual built on Arabic sources.
At a glance
How to read this
This page describes how a historical culture classified dreams, drawn from the texts and the scholars it cites: Macrobius in Stahl's translation, Synesius in the open-access SAPERE edition, Gregory's Dialogues, Augustine, Aquinas, and the studies by Steven Kruger, Patricia Cox Miller and Steven Oberhelman. The medieval writers were Christians writing about a living faith, and their theology is presented as what they held, not judged. Their classifications are not claims about how dreams work, and the dream books are catalogues of what a culture believed, not evidence of anything. Where a point is disputed, such as the date and sources of Achmet, the page says so and names the scholar.
Around 400 CE a Roman grammarian named Macrobius wrote a commentary on the dream of Scipio, the closing episode of Cicero's Republic, and in the course of it set down a classification of dreams that Europe used for the next thousand years. There were five kinds. Three were worth attention: the somnium, an enigmatic dream whose meaning is hidden in images and needs interpreting; the visio, in which what the sleeper sees comes to pass as seen; and the oraculum, in which a parent, a priest or a god appears and says plainly what will happen. Two were not: the insomnium, the ordinary dream thrown up by the day's worries or the body's state, and the visum, which the Greeks called phantasma, the apparition that comes in the moment between waking and sleep.
The scheme was useful because it was a filter. It told a reader which dreams to dismiss before asking what any of them meant, and it drew the line in the same place as the Christian writers who came after, who worried less about meaning than about trust. Chaucer's dreamers argue over it. The site's page on dreams in ancient Rome has the five kinds with their examples; this page follows what happened to them.
The same decades produced three Christian treatments of the dream that pulled in different directions. Augustine, in the twelfth book of his literal commentary on Genesis, written to explain how Paul could have been caught up to the third heaven, distinguished three kinds of vision: corporeal, what the eye sees; spiritual, what the mind sees in images, which is where dreams belong; and intellectual, the seeing of truth without images at all. The taxonomy was cited for a thousand years whenever a theologian needed to say what sort of thing a dream was. Augustine's own letter on the physician Gennadius, who was told inside a dream that he was dreaming, is on the history of lucid dreaming.
Synesius of Cyrene, a Greek philosopher of the Platonic school who ended his life as a bishop in Libya, wrote On Dreams soon after 400 with a warmer view. Dreams, he argued, are the one kind of prophecy open to everyone, rich and poor, men and women, free and slave, because the imagination through which they come belongs to every soul. The second half of his short book is practical: attend to your dreams and keep a record of them, a night-book beside the day-book. It is the earliest surviving argument for a dream diary.
Gregory the Great, pope from 590, took the cautious line that the Latin church mostly kept. In the fourth book of his Dialogues he lists six origins of a dream: a full stomach, an empty one, illusion, thought mixed with illusion, revelation, and thought mixed with revelation. The first two are the body, the middle two are the devil, and only the last two come from God, which means a dreamer cannot tell from inside which kind is which. His advice follows: the holy should be slow to trust dreams, since the enemy can counterfeit them. For most of the Middle Ages that was the official position, and the popular dream books thrived in spite of it.
Theory was for the learned. Everyone else had a list. The Somniale Danielis, the Dream Book of Daniel, is an alphabetical catalogue of dream images with a one-line verdict for each, good or bad for the dreamer, and it survives in Latin manuscripts from the ninth century to the end of the fifteenth, the most copied dream book of the Middle Ages. Daniel did not write it. Much of its material descends from Artemidorus, the one Greek dream manual to survive from antiquity, and it was translated into the vernaculars as they arose. Steven Kruger's Dreaming in the Middle Ages sets it beside the theorists, which is the right way to read it: the two traditions ran in parallel and rarely met.
The Greek East produced something between the two. The Oneirocriticon of Achmet, a long dream manual in Greek, was for centuries taken by Western scholars for a translation of the Arab interpreter Ibn Sirin, because its preface claims Eastern authorities. Maria Mavroudi showed in 2002 that it is a Christian work of the tenth century which drew on Arabic manuals, and Steven Oberhelman translated it into English in 1991. It is the clearest case of the dream book crossing between the three faiths of the Mediterranean, and the site's page on Ibn Sirin tells the Arabic side.
Two medieval figures tested the categories from inside. Hildegard of Bingen insisted, in a letter of 1175, that her visions came neither in dreams nor in sleep nor in ecstasy but awake, with her eyes open, which placed them outside every classification on this page and is why the church could approve them. She is on the Women and Dreams timeline. Thomas Aquinas, in the Summa Theologiae, asked whether divination by dreams is unlawful and answered with a distinction that became the rule: it depends on the cause. A dream caused by the body, by the surroundings, or by God through the ministry of angels may be read; a dream caused by demons may not, and consulting them is superstition. The lawfulness of reading a dream turned on where it came from, which was Gregory's problem restated as a method.
The system ended where the Renaissance began. In 1562 Girolamo Cardano, physician, mathematician and gambler, published in Basel four books of Synesian Dreams, named for the bishop who had told everyone to keep a night-book, and ended them with fifty-five of his own dreams, recorded in the years after his son was executed in 1560. It is the first European dream book that is also a dream diary, and the line from it runs to Hervey de Saint-Denys, to Freud, and to the journal a member keeps on this site.
The medieval theory of dreams was not one doctrine but a conversation across six centuries, and four writers set its terms. Steven Kruger traces the whole of it from the Neoplatonists to the late Middle Ages; Patricia Cox Miller reads the late antique dreamers, Perpetua among them, on their own terms; Steven Oberhelman translated the Byzantine manual.
Rome, c. 400. Commentary on the Dream of Scipio: five kinds of dream, three worth reading, two not. The scheme the Middle Ages inherited.
Cyrene and Ptolemais, c. 400. On Dreams: prophecy through dreams is open to everyone, and everyone should keep a night-book.
Rome, pope 590 to 604. Dialogues, book four: six origins of dreams, two from the body, two from the devil, two from God, so be slow to trust them.
Byzantium, tenth century. The Oneirocriticon, a Greek dream manual drawing on Arabic sources, once mistaken for Ibn Sirin; translated by Oberhelman in 1991.
A grammarian's commentary on Cicero fixes the classification of dreams that medieval Europe will use for a thousand years.
Commentary → Five kinds → ChaucerA Platonist who will become a bishop argues that dreams are the prophecy open to all and that the way to study them is to write them down.
Philosophy → Diary → CardanoIn the Dialogues the pope explains that a dreamer cannot tell from inside whether a dream comes from the stomach, the devil or God.
Six origins → Caution → Church policyAsked whether her visions come in dreams, sleep or ecstasy, the abbess answers none of these, with her eyes open, in her soul.
Vision → Not a dream → ApprovedDid you know the Middle Ages sorted dreams before interpreting them? Macrobius's five kinds were a filter: the insomnium from the day and the visum at the edge of sleep were set aside as meaningless before anyone asked what the somnium meant.
Did you know a bishop around 400 told everyone to keep a dream diary? Synesius of Cyrene argued that dreams are the one prophecy open to rich and poor alike and that the way to study them is a night-book kept beside the day-book.
Did you know the most copied medieval dream book was not written by Daniel? The Somniale Danielis, an alphabetical list of dream images with good or bad verdicts, survives in Latin manuscripts from the ninth to the fifteenth century and descends in part from Artemidorus.
Did you know a Greek dream book was mistaken for an Arabic one for centuries? The Oneirocriticon of Achmet was long taken for a translation of Ibn Sirin. Maria Mavroudi showed in 2002 that it is a tenth-century Christian work drawing on Arabic manuals.
In two ways that rarely met. The learned used classifications: Macrobius's five kinds of dream, Augustine's three kinds of vision, Gregory the Great's six origins, and later Aquinas's rule that a dream may be read if its cause is natural or divine and not if it is demonic. Everyone else used a dream book, above all the Somniale Danielis, an alphabetical list of dream images with a good or bad verdict for each, copied across Europe from the ninth century to the fifteenth.
In his Commentary on the Dream of Scipio, written around 400 CE, Macrobius named the somnium, an enigmatic dream whose meaning is hidden in images; the visio, which comes true as seen; the oraculum, in which an authority appears and speaks; the insomnium, the ordinary dream caused by the day's cares or the body; and the visum, the apparition between waking and sleep. The first three were worth interpreting and the last two were not.
It discouraged trusting dreams and forbade divination by them when the dream's source was demonic, which was the point of Gregory the Great's six origins: a dreamer cannot tell from inside whether a dream comes from the stomach, the devil or God. Thomas Aquinas made the rule precise. Reading a dream caused by the body, the surroundings or God is lawful; consulting one caused by demons is superstition. The dream books went on being copied regardless.
A long dream manual in Greek from tenth-century Byzantium, which claims Eastern authorities in its preface and was for centuries taken for a translation of the Arab interpreter Ibn Sirin. Maria Mavroudi showed in 2002 that it is a Christian work drawing on Arabic dream books. Steven Oberhelman translated it into English in 1991. It is the clearest case of a dream book crossing between the Christian and Muslim worlds.
The most popular dream book of the Middle Ages: an alphabetical list of dream images, each with a verdict that the dream bodes something good or bad for the dreamer. It carries the prophet Daniel's name without his authorship, draws part of its material from Artemidorus, and survives in Latin manuscripts from the ninth century to the end of the fifteenth, with translations into the vernaculars. Lawrence Martin edited the Latin text in 1981.
A Greek philosopher of the Platonic school, born in Cyrene in Libya, who became bishop of Ptolemais in the last years of his life. His short book On Dreams, written soon after 400, argues that dreams are a form of prophecy open to everyone, since the imagination they come through belongs to every soul, and that the way to study them is to keep a night-book. It is the earliest surviving case for a dream diary, and the open-access SAPERE edition of 2014 has the Greek, an English translation and essays.
Cambridge University Press. The theory of dreaming from the Neoplatonists and the Church Fathers to the late Middle Ages, set beside the popular dream books such as the Somniale Danielis.
View in Sources ↗Princeton University Press. Pagan, Jewish and Christian dreamers of the late Roman world, Perpetua, Hermas, Aelius Aristides and Jerome among them, read as a culture imagining itself.
View in Sources ↗Texas Tech University Press. The complete English translation of the Byzantine dream manual, with its claimed Eastern sources.
View in Sources ↗Kept together, they begin to show a thread. The Dream Journal letter arrives on the 1st and the 15th: one symbol read closely, one honest idea from the science of sleep.
Free · Twice a month max · One-click unsubscribe
And if you want to keep the dreams themselves: the Companion plan keeps what you cannot see alone.
Muslims have brought dreams to a decision for centuries, with istikhara and with care about which dreams to trust. This reading does not tell you what to do. It reads the dream with you and leaves the decision yours.
Read Your DreamNo account needed · Room for the whole dream · Private by design