A row of trees in an infrared photograph, their leaves gold and the clouds sepia, a scene in neither color nor black and white
◐☽✦◈◎◇

Do We Dream in Color, or in Black and White?

Ask a room today and nearly everyone says color. Ask the same question in 1942 and seven in ten said rarely or never. Dreams did not change in those sixty years, but film and television did, which leaves a strange possibility on the table: that people were wrong about their own dreams then, or are wrong now, or that the question has no clean answer at all.

In essence

Most people today report dreaming in color, and when sleepers are woken during REM sleep and asked at once, about four dreams in five contain some color. The answer has a history: in 1942, 70.7 percent of American students said they rarely or never dreamed in color, in 2001 only 17.7 percent did, and people over 55 who grew up with black and white media still report about a quarter of their dreams in greyscale. The researchers' own conclusion is that we may not know how we dream, only how we think we dream.

At a glance

  • Woken in the laboratory during REM sleep and asked immediately, people describe some color in about 83 percent of their dreams (Kahn and colleagues, 1962); asked the next morning without the prompt, the figure fell to about a quarter, which says as much about memory as about dreams.
  • In 1942 Middleton asked 277 students how often they saw color in dreams and 70.7 percent said rarely or never. Eric Schwitzgebel asked 124 students the same questions in 2001 and 17.7 percent said so; the answer never went from 39.9 percent to 4.4. The decades between are the decades of black and white film.
  • Eva Murzyn at Dundee in 2008 compared sixty people, half under 25 and half over 55, with diaries and questionnaires: those who had grown up with only black and white media reported greyscale dreams about a quarter of the time, the young 4.4 percent, and the two ways of asking agreed.

Where the science stands

What is established: the laboratory figures from REM awakenings, the questionnaire shift between 1942 and 2001, the Chinese replication across groups with different histories of color media, and the Dundee difference between generations. What is open is the thing that matters most. Nobody has shown whether black and white media changed what people dream or only what they believe about their dreams, and the researchers say so in their own papers. A dream is reported after the fact, by a mind that did not note the colors at the time, and a question like 'was it in color' asks for a judgement most dreamers never made while dreaming.

So this page does not tell you how you dream. It tells you what people have answered when asked, and why the answers moved. If you want to know about your own dreams, the one method that beats memory is the one the laboratories used: write the dream down the moment you wake, before the day has had a chance to repaint it, and notice whether color is even something you can say. Many people find they cannot, and that is a finding too. A dream that comes in grey is not a sign of anything about your mood or your sight, and the colors a dream does carry are read here, as everywhere on this site, through what they mean to you and never from a table.

The laboratory

What people say when you wake them

The cleanest numbers come from the first decade of sleep laboratories. In 1962 Edwin Kahn, William Dement and colleagues woke sleepers during REM sleep, the phase in which most vivid dreaming happens, and asked them at once whether the dream had color in it. About 83 percent of the dreams did. The same team found that when people were asked about their dreams later, without the awakening, color was mentioned in only about a quarter of reports. The two numbers together are the whole puzzle in miniature: the dream had color when it was caught fresh, and lost it in the hours before it was told.

Later laboratory work kept finding color whenever the asking was close to the dreaming. What it could not settle is what the color is like. Dreamers who are asked carefully often say the color was there but not attended to, the way the color of a wall is there while you talk in front of it. A dream, in other words, may be in color in the sense that a scene is, without the dreamer ever having looked at the colors, and that is why the question 'was it in color or black and white' is harder than it sounds.

The history

1942, 2001, and the years of black and white film

In 1942 the psychologist Warren Middleton asked 277 college students how often they saw colors in their dreams. 70.7 percent answered rarely or never, and 39.9 percent answered never. Through the 1940s and 1950s it was ordinary for textbooks to say that dreams were mostly black and white and that a colored dream was unusual, worth noting, perhaps meaningful. Then the opinion vanished. In 2001 the philosopher Eric Schwitzgebel put Middleton's questionnaire to 124 students at the University of California and only 17.7 percent answered rarely or never; 4.4 percent said never. His paper of 2003 reports the two tables side by side, and his paper of 2002 asks the question in its title: why did we think we dreamed in black and white?

His answer is the one that has stuck. The years in which educated Americans believed their dreams were black and white are the years in which the moving pictures they watched were black and white, and the belief faded as color film and color television came in. In 2006 Schwitzgebel, with Changbing Huang and Yifeng Zhou, tested the idea in China, where color media arrived at different times in different places: three groups of similar age but different histories of color television, and the groups with the longer history reported more colored dreaming. The study has a fair objection on record, that the groups also differed in being rural or urban, and Schwitzgebel does not claim more than the pattern shows.

The generations

Dundee, 2008: the people who grew up before color

The sharpest test came from Eva Murzyn at the University of Dundee in 2008. She took sixty people, thirty under 25 and thirty over 55, and asked them two ways: a questionnaire about their dreams in general, and a diary in which each dream was written down on waking and rated for color. The older group had grown up with black and white film and television, the younger with color. Among the over-55s who had known only black and white media as children, about a quarter of the dreams were reported in greyscale. Among the young, 4.4 percent were. And the two methods agreed, which matters, because one explanation of the whole puzzle had been that questionnaires measure beliefs while diaries measure dreams.

Murzyn's own reading is cautious and worth keeping. Her data show that people with early black and white media report more greyscale dreams and that the difference survives the diary. They do not show whether the media shaped the dreams or shaped the memory of them, and she says so. The British Psychological Society's summary of the paper ends on the same note: we do not know whether early exposure changed the form of the dreams or only the beliefs about them. That is the state of the question today.

What it means for you

A dream in grey, a dream in color

Three plain things follow. First, if your dreams seem to be in black and white, nothing is wrong with you, your eyes or your mood; it is a common report, commoner among people who grew up before color television, and it may describe how you remember rather than how you dream. Second, if you want to know, the only method with any standing is the laboratory's, scaled down: write the dream the moment you wake and note color before anything else, because color is the first thing the day repaints. Third, the colors a dream does carry are not a code. A red door or a grey sea means what red and grey mean to you, and the reading this site offers asks that before it says anything.

The deeper lesson is the one Schwitzgebel drew and built a career on: people are less reliable witnesses to their own experience than they assume, and dreams are the clearest case. A whole generation was confident about the color of its dreams and the next generation was confident of the opposite, and sleep did not change. It is a good thing to carry into any reading of a dream, including the ones on this site. The dream you tell is already a translation, and the colors are the first thing lost in it.

Did you know…

Facts That Will Surprise You

☽

Did you know seven in ten students in 1942 said they rarely or never dreamed in color? Warren Middleton's questionnaire of 277 students found 70.7 percent answering rarely or never. The same questions put to 124 students in 2001 by Eric Schwitzgebel got 17.7 percent.

☽

Did you know color is found in about four REM dreams in five when the sleeper is woken at once? Kahn, Dement and colleagues reported in 1962 that about 83 percent of dreams recalled on REM awakenings had some color, against about a quarter of dreams recalled later without the prompt.

☽

Did you know people who grew up with black and white television still report greyscale dreams? In Eva Murzyn's 2008 study at Dundee, the over-55s who had known only black and white media as children reported about a quarter of their dreams in greyscale; the under-25s reported 4.4 percent.

◐

Whatever color it came in

Write the dream down as it was, the grey and the gold alike, and bring it here. The reading asks what the colors meant to you before it says anything about them.

Read Your Dream

Free · No account needed · Your dream is not stored

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Do people dream in color or black and white?

Mostly in color, by every measure that asks close to the dream. When sleepers are woken during REM sleep and asked at once, about 83 percent of dreams contain some color (Kahn and colleagues, 1962). Asked later from memory, far fewer people mention color, and a minority of people, more often those who grew up with black and white film and television, report that some or most of their dreams are in greyscale. Whether that describes the dreams or the memory of them is not settled.

Why did people once think they dreamed in black and white?

Because they were asked during the years of black and white film. In 1942, 70.7 percent of American students said they rarely or never dreamed in color; in 2001, with the same questions, 17.7 percent said so. Eric Schwitzgebel, who ran the 2001 study and traced the history, argues that the belief rose and fell with black and white media, and a 2006 replication in China found more reported color in groups with a longer history of color television. Dreams themselves did not change; opinions about them did.

Why do I dream in black and white?

It is a common report and not a sign of anything wrong. In a 2008 Dundee study, people over 55 who had grown up with only black and white media reported about a quarter of their dreams in greyscale, against one in twenty-five among people under 25, and the pattern held in dream diaries as well as questionnaires. Researchers do not know whether early media changed the dreams or the way they are remembered. If you want to check your own, write the dream down the moment you wake and note color first, before memory repaints it.

Does the color of a dream mean something?

Not from a table. Dream colors have no agreed meanings in research, and the colors a dream carries are read here through what they mean to the dreamer, the same way as any other image. A grey dream is not a sign of low mood and a vivid one is not a sign of anything in particular; what people report about color depends heavily on when and how they are asked. The one solid finding is about memory: color is among the first things a dream loses between waking and telling.

How do scientists know what dreams look like?

By waking people in a sleep laboratory, usually during REM sleep, and asking immediately, which is the closest anyone can get to the dream itself. Those studies, from Kahn and colleagues in 1962 onward, find color in most dreams. Everything else, questionnaires and morning diaries included, measures the dream as remembered, and the gap between the two is the subject of this page. The philosopher Eric Schwitzgebel has used the history of the black and white question to argue that people are poor witnesses to their own experience in general.

Recommended reading

Go Deeper

Do People Still Report Dreaming in Black and White? An Attempt to Replicate a Questionnaire from 1942Eric Schwitzgebel (2003)

Perceptual and Motor Skills. Middleton's 1942 questionnaire put to students again in 2001, and the two tables side by side: 70.7 percent rarely or never, then 17.7.

View in Sources ↗
Why Did We Think We Dreamed in Black and White?Eric Schwitzgebel (2002)

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science. The history of the opinion, from Aristotle to the sleep laboratory, and the case that it tracked the film people watched.

View in Sources ↗
Do We Only Dream in Colour? A Comparison of Reported Dream Colour in Younger and Older Adults with Different Experiences of Black and White MediaEva Murzyn (2008)

Consciousness and Cognition. Sixty people, two generations, diaries and questionnaires, and a quarter of the older group's dreams in greyscale.

View in Sources ↗

One dream is a night.

Kept together, they begin to show a thread. The Dream Journal letter arrives on the 1st and the 15th: one symbol read closely, one honest idea from the science of sleep.

Free · Twice a month max · One-click unsubscribe

And if you want to keep the dreams themselves: the Companion plan keeps what you cannot see alone.